Consider key objectionsdevelop counter arguments point out flawsweaknesses in arguments on the other side list objections. The times editorial page editor, andrew rosenthal, states that times editorials, unlike those at other newspapers that do present an opposing argument, if only to knock it down, do not necessarily present or even take into account the opposing position. Click on the image below or the link to download the printable pdf file. Our argumentative worksheets are free to download and easy to access in pdf. By the end of the unit, students will have produced fully developed arguments. A counterargument is an argument opposed to your thesis or part of your thesis. Persuasive writing students will practice seeing the other point of view by completing a worksheet in which they develop an argument and counterargument for a wide range of social issues.
Constructing an argument student learning advisory service. In the counter argument, the conclusion sentence becomes your rebuttal. Three different prompts my students are allowed to choose from, including some resources they may use as their resea. Moreover, the addition of numbers is crucial for the accuracy of the claim. Strategies for teaching argumentative writing integrating reading and writing. Just avoid making new claims that need lots of additional support. These activities help them learn to brainstorm points quickly and to choose the side of an argument that is easier for them to support when writing a persuasive essay. Teaching counter arguments to students linkedin slideshare. Select the purple tutorials button on the left of the screen. The counterargument is in the topic sentence position of the sbj method. For the authenticity of a claim, the writer needs to add numbers and figures in his work. Persuasive essay worksheet lincoln 8th grade science.
By anticipating disagreement with your argument and persuasively arguing against it in your rebuttal, you convince your reader to trust you and your claim. Counter argumentpersuasive essay sentencestarters free pdf ebook download. Those who disagree are against these ideas may say assert. This is a worksheet that can be used after you have already taught concession and counterargument. Oct 18, 2016 this resource is a planning tool to help pupils develop their planning skills and writing skills of nonfiction argument persuasion texts. Argument and counterargument lesson with resources. When you write an academic essay, you make an argument. You complete the supporting detail, textual evidence, and explanation as if you are arguing for the opposing side. Its fine to introduce new information or quotations in your conclusions, as long as the new points grow from your argument. Thorough and wellorganized, this lesson plan helps pupils to weigh, build, and refute an argument the latter of which is featured here. Sabotage an argument by using counterargument teaching. A lesson on arguments and counter arguments aimed at set 2 y7 class.
Aug 19, 2015 the counterargument could even be just one or two sentences within a paragraph, usually in the introduction or conclusion. Refutation counterargument exercise when writing a persuasive paper, your argument will be much stronger if you identify an opposing argument counterargument and explain why that argument is less effective. A collection of downloadable worksheets, exercises and activities to teach argumentative essay, shared by english language teachers. Naturally, what you dont want to do is present a counterargument and not address it. In fact, in an argument paper, presenting the other. But this could be used for 7th10th grade classrooms when adapted to fit student needs. Log on to ecampus and click on online english corner in the my organizations area. Arguing both sides worksheet 3 here is yet another doublesided worksheet where students practice brainstorming arguments on both sides of controversial persuasive essay topics. Students write counter argument sentences appropriate for each topic and picture. This is a comprehensive argument essay unit i use with my 8th graders. To make your argument, you need to defeat the arguments of people who hold the opposite view the counterargument. Therefore, since writing a persuasive essay doesnt require any research, students will continue to be tested on their ability to write. Others may say that but i argue a common argument against this position is.
It is important to reveal the flaws of the counterargument. Counter argument displaying top 8 worksheets found for this concept some of the worksheets for this concept are counter argument and rebuttal, writing a counterargument and refutation, lesson skill counterarguments, work outline for analyticalargument essays, synthesis essay instructions and work, making concessions counterarguments, arguments work, body paragraph. Counterclaimdanunzio name period date counterclaim. Students need to learn how to write persuasive essays. Writing a research paper may be more difficult, but students cant be expected write one in an hour.
Your parents ask you to give up some of your video game time to play. Remember that there is an important difference between data and an argument. The smart snacking choice time for us to bash processed foods. I provide details, reasons, and examples to support my point of view. Writing worksheets persuasive writing creating arguments and counterarguments. Statements that are backed up by reasons, facts, and examples related to the topic. When you counter argue, you consider a possible argument against your thesis or some part of your reasoning and then state why your claim is still valid. You may also wish to add your own sentence stems to the list below.
Your thesis is smoking should be allowed on campus. Why i hate facebook this author goes as far to say that social networking can cause you physical harm. Counter argument sentence writing practice for writing students to help them develop. The writer will acknowledge a counter argument to argue against it.
Argument writing cheat sheet purpose to inform an audience that your viewpoint deserves consideration strategy to present information on both sides of an issue by favoring one side and casting reasonable doubt about the merits of the other side phrases while it is true that opponents will claim in spite of the fact style logical. I write with an active voice and show how i feel about the issue through my writing. Explain that the debate that they had with their parent was an exercise in counter arguments. In writing, an argument is a text that expresses the authors position about a topic and why that position is correct. Once you have identified any problemshazards represented by the opposition, you. The majority of high schools have kept the same starting time that existed in the 1920s. Persuasive writing and argument writing cheat sheets. I understand that some students are already using cell phones in class without permission, but because they know that they are breaking the rules, they are more careful. An argument is an opinion supported with persuasivelystated evidence. Sample prompts that appeal to students 65 opinion argument reading and writing vocabulary 6667 writing checklist. Whenever you present an argument in your works, you must add a proper explanation and description to it and give your readers a solid reason to agree with whatever you have argued. Counterclaimdanunzio name period date counterclaim activity. Signposting stems for an introduction to understand the role of. In this worksheet, students will practice writing counterarguments and.
Students will practice seeing the other point of view by completing a worksheet in which they develop an argument and counterargument for a wide range of social issues. A counterclaim or counterargument should also be taken into consideration. That said, our search reveals that plenty of counterarguments can be found in the opinion pages, such as in this aptly named piece. Counter argument displaying top 8 worksheets found for this concept some of the worksheets for this concept are counter argument and rebuttal, writing a counterargument and refutation, lesson skill counterarguments, work outline for analyticalargument essays, synthesis essay instructions and work, making concessions counterarguments, arguments work, body paragraph example. You might be interested in the introduction to argument tutorial on ecampus.
Changing my personal purchasing habits will not be enough to affect the profits of major companies. You would just need to print the resources and youre good to go. Counter argument sentence writing practice for writing students. Includes sentences starters and an example of how to write a counter argument and rebuttal to a given claim. The power point has resources a letter and a technique poster incorporated. This table shows an argument, counter argument, and one possible rebuttal to this counter argument. Nevertheless, some critics argue that the reason why some terminally ill patients wish to commit suicide is nothing more than melancholia. You have to 1 state your opinion, 2 give reasons to support your opinion, and 3 argue against the opposite opinion. In this worksheet, students will practice writing counterarguments and rebuttals to help them in their persuasive essay writing. Distinguishing a claim from a counterclaim worksheet a. Distinguishing a claim from a counterclaim worksheet. The counter argument is in the topic sentence position of the sbj method.
The counterargument lesson plan that follows has been designed, tested, and refined to better help students understand counterargument as a complex and delicate rhetorical strategy, rather than the simple mentioning of an opposing viewpoint. Argument counter argument rebuttal the primary focus in medical endoflife decisions should be on patient consent, rather than doctor intention, because it is not a breach against a patients rights if she consents to the. Counterclaim the counterclaim is simply the claim of the opposing viewpoint or the opposing argument. Upgrade to premium membership to assign worksheets, games, and more to your child.
New points might be more general, answering the so what question. When you counter argue, you consider a possible argument againstyour thesis or some aspect of your reasoning it presents you as the kind of person who weighs alternatives before arguing for. Rebuttals may focus on the counterclaim itself rather than the entire opposing argument, particular points of its support argument, or they may simply focus the argument as a whole. This 9slide powerpoint presentation introduces students to vocabulary they will encounter when writing an argument, including claim, reasons, evidence, counterargument, and rebuttal. Counter argument persuasive essay sentence starters download or read online ebook counter argument persuasive essay sentence starters in pdf format from the best user guide databaseelements of persuasiveargument papers. Its purpose was to make time for studens to get back to their farms and tend to chores. This exercise helps students learn how to use and become familiar with transitions in argument essays. Counterarguments in toefl writing magoosh toefl blog. This week, we are going to be working on strong vs. It expresses the view of a person who disagrees with your position oldham. Brief definitions of claim, counter argument, and rebuttal.
A counterargument can appear anywhere in your essay, but it most commonly appears. However, if schools used violence as a punishment, pupils may come to believe that violence is an acceptable way of behaving and therefore become more violent themselves mobile phones are a waste of money since landlines are much cheaper. Perfect for fourth and fifth graders, this writing process resource also provides sentence frames to get them started. Argument writing middle school during argument writing, students are learning how to establish a claim, use evidence from textmedia to support their claim, and then include their reasoning behind why they chose that evidence and how it ties to their claim. Key features of arguments a clear and arguable position necessary background information persuasive points for your argument. Argument writing middle school common sense education. Writing a counterargument and refutation counterargument the counterargument paragraph is developed in much the same way that an argument paragraph is developed. To convince the audience, your essay must be balancedit must include your viewpoint and the opposing viewpoint, or counterargument. Introduction weighing the evidence evaluating an argument lesson 18 an argument isnt just a disagreement with your best friend about what to do on saturday afternoon. Explorers argument advertisement and essay 5962 cues, sequences, and transition words 6364 ideas for opinion argument writing. Transition words for argument writing introducing examples that is to say in other words for example for instance namely an example of this as in the following examples such as including especially particularly in particular notably chiefly mainly mostly writing in listssequence firstly secondly thirdly another yet another in addition. Persuasive writing creating arguments and counterarguments. This is done so that the writer can develop and explain his or her opinion more fully. Some students are already illegally using cell phones in classes and they don.
This quiz and worksheet combination will test your. Claim reasons evidence counterclaim counterargument conclusion. Counterarguments are a method of persuasion used by writers, lawyers, and anytime someone is involved in a debate. Overall, you must convince the audience that your side of the argument is correct. Counter arguments must be considered tailor the argument to fit the audience. Persuasive writing for grade 3 my introduction hooks the reader and shows i am clear about the point of view i want to argue. We offer carefully designed phonics worksheets, games, videos and flash cards you will find on our site. As i said before, a counter argument is an explanation of an argument the writer disagrees with. In an argumentative essay, your job is make the reader agree with your opinion about a controversial topic. To help students understand the fundamentals of the two genres categories on the cheat sheets include. Youll certainly want to stick with just one argument for most of the essay, even if you do address a counterargument. Aug 31, 2015 in my last post on this subject, i talked about using counter arguments in toefl independent writing. Thus, there is no reason for me to pay more for my chocolate since it wont make a difference. You think students should be allowed to smoke on campus.
By the end of this presentation, you should be able to understand the characteristics of an argument. Have students complete a t chart with their name at the top of one column and their parents at the top of the other, then have them fill in the chart with the arguments that each side used. Only adding an argument without explaining the basis of favoring it is the biggest mistake a writer can commit. Counterargument and rebuttal what is a counterargument. What should be included in the counterargument rebuttal paragraph. It has 4 persuasive prompts and asks students to use a tchart to brainstorm both sides of the issue, develop a thesis, and then write a concession and counterargument. And again, it is possible to leave the counterargument out completely and still get a good score. Counter argument sentence writing practice for writing. Introduce precise claims, distinguish the claims from alternate or opposing claims, and create an organization that establishes clear relationships among claims, counterclaims, reasons, and evidence. You may need to adapt certain words and phrases for your own purposes. Now that we know what a counter argument is and how to use it, lets look at some examples. Counter argument when you write a persuasive essay, you make an argument.
1544 132 732 950 479 1603 1437 440 550 532 99 1473 69 257 948 593 1591 461 1114 359 1413 335 762 510 1178 324 233 369 545 882 716 103 513 1264 304 771 951 1191 220 509 744